Disney Because

Everyone of every age finds a special kind of magic created just for them on a Disney cruise. Young cruisers are off to the most spectacular kids’ area afloat, where they can party with pirates and play with Disney princesses. Teens get their own private club, parties, activities and more. While adults escape to exclusive areas whether it’s a pampering spa treatment, dancing to the music at a cool club or enjoying a romantic dinner. Everyone can enjoy their very own cruise; then, gather together to share the most magical moments of all, family time.
References :
I went on it )

For our family, there was no comparison- Disney all the way!!! Disney’s ships are so much nicer, cleaner, and the staff on Disney cruises goes out of their way to make sure everyone is satisfied. Disney was the perfect vacation for us because it had activities for all members of our family and we felt very safe with our children there. On Carnival, every time we turned around, we saw some questionable behaviors and LOTS of drinking all the time- even early in the morning!!! So, for us- definitely Disney.
References :

Carnival has much larger cabins, way better food, and costs 1/3 to 1/2 as much. Disney, on the other hand, has hysterical fans, who have all drank the Kool-Aid; the same ones who have bought the Fantasia video three times because it is the last time it will ever be sold.

Let’s face it, there is a reason Carnival is the biggest, with 29 ships – they provide a superior product at an affordable price, while Disney, which has been in the cruise business almost as long, has never had more than 3 boats in the water at once.
References :